By Renate Cooper
05/14/2007
Abstract
“Beethoven, music and the Deaf” is based on new ideas and
technology. Technology today is enabling Deaf people to hear
and enjoy music. Educational Institutions will soon have the
opportunity to utilize new tools that will enable deaf
students to hear, study and appreciate music. Beethoven used
vibration to hear his music. A device allowing the Deaf to
feel the vibrations of different instruments is now being
developed. In addition there are new advancements in
widening the frequency range for cochlear implants. With
today’s technology, music can and should be integrated into
schools and should include deaf students in the curriculum.
Educational Institutions need to be informed of the
availability of these resources as they become available.
Every student should be offered the same opportunities to
experience the world and all it has to offer. Deaf students
should not be an exception.
Beethoven,
Music and The Deaf
A Brief Consideration of the
Works and Struggles of Ludwig Van Beethoven
Recently there was information on the radio regarding Ludwig van
Beethoven, one of the greatest composers in history. The story
talked about how he enjoyed going to the local spa. He loved the
mineral water and mineral baths. When he died the family he lived
with took a lock of his hair. It was passed down through generations
until it was finally donated to a university. With new technologies,
scientists have finally been able to determine how he died. He died,
slowly, from lead poisoning. The report stated that the lead in his
hair sample was many times higher than normal. This would explain
the severe intestinal pain he lived with. His outbursts of rage and
anger were also part of his reaction to the lead poisoning. And
lastly, the poisoning was a contributing factor to his deafness. New
technologies are also being developed to ensure music becomes part
of the curriculum for the deaf and hard of hearing students.
When discussing music and deafness
inevitably there is reference to Beethoven. He is not always
considered the greatest role model for deaf persons because he was a
great composer long before his hearing loss. He learned to
appreciate music at a very young age and gave his first performance
at age seven. Therefore his skills as a composer were engrained by
the time he became deaf. The story that he cut the legs off his
piano in order to feel the vibrations of his music has been heard
over and over. If a man with his talent can hear music by the
vibrations it creates, one wonders how someone profoundly or even
totally deaf at an early age can learn to appreciate music without
ever hearing it.
Think about what it would be like if you could not hear.
What can we learn from Beethoven, his music and his deafness? After
loosing his hearing Beethoven used books with blank pages to
communicate with people. Imagine spending one day trying to
communicate with everyone you came in contact with by writing. In
today’s society it would be almost impossible or at the very least
extremely impractical. Hearing, on the other hand, is relevant to
the situation. If one lives in a big city the noises of traffic, car
horns, boom boxes, and sirens can be heard. It can be very
distracting and very, very irritating. What is really happening? The
big city noise is over powering the real sounds of nature. Someone
living in the country can hear the sounds of crickets chirping,
frogs croaking and birds singing. The sounds of rain and the silence
of a falling snow are true sounds being missed by the deaf and hard
of hearing. Music, in any genre should be heard and appreciated by
everyone. There is no vibration like that which music creates.
There
is some question as to whether or not deaf children should have the
opportunity to have music as part of their curriculum. There can be
a relationship between music and the deaf. Many hearing people are
tone deaf and it is sometimes difficult to hear all of the lyrics
when listening to some music. With proper amplification, many
hard-of-hearing people can enjoy music. In this author’s opinion
some music isn’t worth listening to regardless of whether you can
hear or not. People that are profoundly or totally deaf can
appreciate music by standing next to speakers and feel the
vibrations. Some enjoy the vibration of the drum rather than from
piano or guitar. Many hearing people have rhythm with or with out
music. The same is the case with the deaf. After all, people are
people whether they can hear or not. By not giving deaf children the
opportunity to learn and appreciate music you are creating a
disservice to them. All children should be provided the same level
of education. We need to expose our children to all life has to
offer.
We do
not have to expect our children to aspire to Beethoven’s greatness,
but we do need to allow them every opportunity to be the best at
whatever it is they choose to be. Beethoven’s father and grandfather
were both professional musicians. His father was an alcoholic and
forced Ludwig to practice long hours. Often Beethoven’s father would
drag him out of bed to practice piano or play for guests. Today’s
society will not tolerate such behavior. It would be assumed that
Beethoven would have become a great composer regardless of his
abusive childhood. He had the talent and passion. It is sad to know
that one of the greatest composers in history could not hear his
music. It is amazing to think he wrote some of the world’s greatest
compositions even though he could not hear a note. All children
should have the same opportunity. If never given the opportunity,
society may be missing out on another great composer.
There
is a place for music in the deaf community. The appreciation for
music is individual. Like any other area of study there may not be
an interest, but there should always be the opportunity. Two hundred
years after Beethoven sawed off the legs of his piano the technique
he used to feel the vibrations of the music are slowly becoming
available. There is a new device that allows deaf to feel music. The
“Vibrato” speaker has finger pads that allow different instruments,
rhythm and notes to be felt. Hopefully, this may allow deaf children
the same opportunities to learn and appreciate music as mainstream
students. The vibrato is being design to be connected to a computer
enabling deaf people the ability to compose music. It will allow
them the opportunity to be a part of music classes in a way that
would not have been available to them previously. (BBC News)
There
are other reports beginning to emerge regarding other research that
will enable deaf students more opportunities to study and appreciate
music. One study reported that scientists are working on a cochlear
implant that has a wider frequency range. This new, wider range of
frequency will not only allow the deaf the ability to hear speech
better but music as well. There is a new form of music becoming
popular. “Deaf Raves” are becoming popular in London. It allows
clubbers the ability to feel the vibrations through their bodies
with heavy bass and rhythmic tracks. (BBC News) Deaf people lack
tactile sensations and cannot easily perceive the sounds music
produces. These new technologies will be a welcomed advancement to
education and learning.
One
local, Sacramento researcher, Gail Zimmerman, did an action research
study about how music affected the classroom. The instructor played
music first thing in the morning, as she prepared for her zero hour
humanities class. The student never noticed, or at least never said
anything. The next morning was the same as she prepared for class.
Except this time no music. The students filled the classroom without
notice to the lack of music until one student walked in. What, no
Bambi music?” The student was referring to the new age and classical
music the instructor had been playing. She had an “Aha” moment. How
does music affect learning? The instructor began to incorporate
music into her classroom and her studies. There was discussion of
music related to the topics of study. The students took on the
challenge of finding music related to the classroom discussion. The
students found it easy to locate songs with lyrics referencing
peace, anti-war, patriotism and historical figures. Some of the
students’ comments compared listening to music the same as the
teacher reading a poem. Music made a connection to the studies.
Music helped them to understand concepts of literature not present
previously. It helped connect ideas in forms other than written.
Having music be a part of the classroom experience helped the
students relax. They were calm. Adding music to the curriculum was a
more colorful way of learning.
If
one instructor can make a difference in the learning experience of
one classroom of students imagine what learning would be like to
millions of others, including Deaf students. The more opportunity we
allow our children to experience the world around them, the more we
can expect from them in the future. Imagine how many Beethoven’s are
out there waiting for someone to give them the opportunity to hear
music. New technologies are just the beginning. Schools need to be
educated about the new technologies becoming available to them so
that deaf children, all children, can learn to love and appreciate
music.
REFERENCES:
BBC News (Last updated
2005, Oct 26) Speakers allow Deaf to Feel Music, retrieved
from website 05/09/2007
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/london/4377428.stm
Capistrano School
(2004-05) Ludwig van Beethoven, Capistrano Elementary School,
retrieved from website, 05/09/2007 http://empire.k12.ca.us/capistrano/mike/capmusic/classical/beethoven/beethove.htm
Wikipedia, the free
encyclopedia, Ludwig van Beethoven, retrieved from website
05/09/2007 No website address
available. Found through Google search; Beethoven, music, deaf
Zak, Omer (Last
updated 1997, Apr. 28) Music and The Deaf, retrieved from
website 05/09/2007 http://www.zak.co.il/deaf-info/old/music.html
Zimmerman, Gail (2005)
The Theme Song From Bambi: Using Popular Music to Enhance
meanings and Ideas in the High School Literature Classes,
website: Teacher Researchers, 05/09/2007 @
leaguetr@csusm.edu